A shared enemy is a quick way to create a sense of “us” in a team. But at what cost?

A shared enemy can bring people together. But when a team builds its sense of “us” around the idea that others are the problem, belonging is created through devaluing them.

I hear statements like these all the time:
◆ “The people at the top have no clue what we actually do.”
◆ “Sales keeps promising things and leaving us to figure out how to deliver them.”
◆ “Head office is completely out of touch with what’s happening on the ground.”

I’m sure I said things like that myself when I was a leader.

The bitter truth is: drawing a line between “us” and “them” really can create a sense of belonging. A shared enemy provides a remarkably quick answer to the question: “Who are we?”
◆ “We’re the ones who have to clean up the mess.”
◆ “We’re the ones who are closer to what’s really going on.”
◆ “We’re the ones who at least still know how to do the job properly.”

You know you’re on the right side. And that creates cohesion.
Production vs. Sales. Headquarters vs. the regions. Business vs. IT.

Having a common “other” reduces complexity and provides relief. It quickly becomes clear which side you belong to. You don’t have to articulate what you stand for. It’s enough to know who you stand against. But then your sense of “us” is built on devaluing “them.”

And that comes at a cost. The other side increasingly becomes “the problem.” Differences turn into moral judgments. And your own part in the dynamic can easily disappear from view.

It’s a fragile kind of identity: it depends on the other side remaining the problem for the team’s sense of “us” to hold together.

That doesn’t mean criticism of the other side is necessarily unjustified. There may be genuine conflicts of interest, poor decisions, hurtful experiences, or a real sense of powerlessness. The other side becomes a shared enemy when specific criticism hardens into a blanket “they are the problem” and the team starts building its own sense of “us” around that judgment.

For leaders, this can be especially tempting. A shared sense of “those people over there” creates closeness with your own team while also allowing you to avoid taking a position yourself. A shared enemy provides identity without requiring you to articulate and own a story about what your team itself stands for. To me, that’s also a way of sidestepping responsibility.

Leaders strongly influence what a team builds its sense of “us” around. What do we want to stand for? What is our contribution as a team? What do we want to be proud of together? Also, and especially, in how we work together with others.

Teams need an honest, shared story about who they are. Developing that self-understanding is a task for the whole team, and especially for its leader. A shared enemy should never become a shortcut to identity.

Lea Dingel • 05.10.2026
Lea Dingel
I’m Lea Dingel,
working with people, teams, and organizations through change. I’m interested in how change can be shaped in a way that remains sustainable without losing sight of the human dimension.